ONE BOOK DOWN, A THOUSAND MORE TO GO.
← After the Epilogue
After the Epilogue

The First Witch of Boston

by Andrea Catalano

0 commentsDNF

This is a controversial fictional story about Margaret Jones, the first woman executed for witchcraft in Massachusetts. The book has mixed reviews and, unfortunately, is now part of my DNF list.

What didn’t work for me

The book summary felt misleading. It is stated that The First Witch of Boston is based on a true story, actual diary entries, and court records. However, after doing deep research, I couldn't find much about Margaret's life before her trial, and most of what is known is found in Governor John Winthrop's journal.

Besides that, the author took creative liberties that I don't think are appropriate, especially when telling the story of someone who actually existed and about whom so little is known. I will explain this point more in the spoilers section.

And last but not least, I could not find the writing style very engaging, which is another reason why I DNF the book.

THE FINAL WORD

Final thoughts

The First Witch of Boston is not a fair representation of who Margaret Jones was, but rather of how Andrea Catalano imagined her. It includes a few factual details, but most of it is invented, which is understandable up to a point.

I don't regret adding this one to my DNF. What about you? Would you read it?

Let me know in the comments!

Let’s talk spoilers

Show spoilers — including the ending

What we know is: Margaret Jones was a real person, from Charlestown, Massachusetts, married to Thomas Jones. She was known for practicing healing, or "physic", as described in Winthrop's journal. Besides her trial, there are not many records available about who she was and her life.

The First Witch of Boston includes personal thoughts, an idea of what Margaret's relationship with Thomas was, her private diary (which is not factual; there is no evidence she had a diary?!), and other details that are fictionalized by Catalano. I believe that is ok, considering there is a huge gap in historical evidence, and an author does need some creativity to add to their story.

However, what upsets me are the experiences added to Margaret's life that have nothing to do with her, and most importantly, NO historical evidence!!!!! This misleads readers when you claim a story is based on facts. While reading the book, I found bits and pieces that were actually true, but that was 10%.

With that in mind, there is no historical evidence that Margaret was raped. What is the purpose of that in the book? We are talking about someone who existed, and I do not think it's fair to attribute those experiences without making a claim that MOST of the story is fictionalized.

This book just upset me. I don't think it honors Margaret's memory.

If you would like to find out more information on Margaret Jones, you can access this link: https://historyofmassachusetts.org/margaret-jones-first-person-executed-for-witchcraft-in-massachusetts/

← More from After the Epilogue

A Little Book Mail? ♡

New reviews, reading lists, and a little bookish joy. Straight to your inbox.

Opening the mailbox…

Confirm by email to join. Unsubscribe anytime. Your address stays private and is used only for this newsletter, delivered with Resend.
A LITTLE BOOKISH COMPANY

Let’s talk books (0)

Big feelings about this book? You’re in good company. Be kind and mark spoilers.

Your comment
Select text to conceal it. Select a spoiler to remove its formatting.

Opening the conversation…